Tuesday, February 16, 2021

8th Circuit Reject Appeal by Governor Noem, AG and Secretary of State today

 

The 8th Circuit today dismissed appeals by both the State Officials (Governor, AG and Secretary of State) and SD Voice regarding legislatively-imposed restrictive measures related to citizen-initiated ballot measures.  The lower court ruled adversely to the State Officials.  The State’s Appeal is dismissed because of a failure of jurisdiction due to the passage of subsequent legislation.  Nonetheless, the lower court’s adverse ruling for State Officials is permitted to stand (not vacated) due to “public interest” underlying its decision.  The Cross is appeal is dismissed and remanded to the lower court for a ruling on omitted issues. 

A copy of the decision is available at

https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/21/02/201262P.pdf