Thursday, September 17, 2020

Two New Decisions by SD Supreme Court today

 

The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning:

 

1)    Labor dispute, Yankton Police Department;

2)   3rd degree rape conviction upheld, causing 3-2 split within Court

 

Summaries follows:

 

FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE v. CITY OF YANKTON, 2020 S.D. 52:  This dispute is summarized in ¶ 1 of the opinion which follows:

 

The Department of Labor determined that sergeants in the Yankton Police Department are ineligible for membership in a collective bargaining unit because they have authority to hire or effectively recommend hiring decisions. The circuit court reversed that decision on appeal, determining sergeants did not have that authority. The City of Yankton appeals the circuit court’s decision. We reverse.

 

The Court’s concluding paragraph, ¶ 27, explains further:

 

The circuit court erred in disturbing the Department’s findings and conclusions and determining that sergeants have no authority to hire or effectively recommend hiring decisions. The record supports the Department’s determination that YPD sergeants are ineligible for membership in the collective bargaining unit because they use independent judgment to hire or effectively recommend hiring. We therefore reverse the circuit court’s decision on this point. Because sergeants do not qualify as public employees eligible for membership in collective bargaining units, we forgo reviewing whether the sergeants have authority to suspend or discipline or effectively recommend suspension or discipline.

 

This decision is unanimous by the Court, with opinion authored by Chief Justice Gilbertson.

 

STATE v. JACKSON, 2020 S.D. 53:

 

Defendant was convicted by jury of 3rd degree rape in regard to a 56 year old victim who suffered dementia and who was residing a 24 hour care facility.   The SD Supreme Court affirmed, rejecting Defendant’s arguments on appeal.  The Court’s affirmance is unanimous as to result (5-0), but otherwise split (3-2).  The majority opinion is authored by Justice DeVaney and it represents the views of Justice Salter and Justice Jensen.  Circuit Judge Myron sat on this case in lieu of Justice Kern.

 

Chief Justice Gilbertson filed a concurring opinion in regard to the issue as to whether the State must show knowledge by the Defendant of the victim’s lack of capacity in the application of SDCL 22-22-1(3).  Chief Justice Gilbertson expresses the belief that the Court should expressly overrule State v. Jones, 2011 S.D. 60, 804 N.W.2d 409 (state must prove defendant knew or reasonably should have known the victim was too intoxicated to consent).  Circuit Judge Myron agrees with Chief Justice Gilbertson on this issue.   

 

These decisions may be accessed at

 

http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .

 

Thursday, September 10, 2020

SD Supreme Court hands down 1 decision today

 

The SD Supreme Court handed down one decision this morning, holding inter alia:  

 

1)    Divorce court reversed for setting aside “partially gifted” land in favor of H

 Summary follows: 

FIELD v. FIELD, 2020 S.D. 51:  During their marriage, H & W received farmland from H's relative at significantly discounted purchase price.  In this divorce proceeding, the trial court treated the transfer as a "partial gift" made solely to H.  The SD Supreme Court reversed and remanded, holding that, “entire value of the [farmland] should be subject to equitable division.”  This opinion confirms that existing SD rule the grant of an interest in real estate jointly to both H & W, “can be convincing evidence of the realty's status as marital property,” and it also recognizes, "that spouses can provide valuable contributions to the acquisition and maintenance of inherited or gifted property by acting as homemakers or working separately to assist the other spouse in maintaining inherited or gifted property." 

This decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Salter.

This decision may be accessed at

 http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .

 

 

 

Thursday, September 3, 2020

Nonresident convicted of ordinance affecting water supply of city

 

The SD Supreme Court handed down one decision this morning, holding inter alia:  

 

1)    Nonresident convicted of ordinance affecting water supply of city

 

Summary follows:

 

CITY OF RAPID CITY v. SCHAUB, 2020 S.D. 50:   Pro Se Defendant, living outside the city limits, appeals his conviction for “operating an onsite wastewater system without a permit.”  The SD Supreme Court affirmed the conviction rejecting three arguments: 1) that the ordinance was applied in an ex post facto manner; 2) that the City Ordinance was preempted by state law/regulations; and 3) that the City lacked authority to exercise police powers outside of its city limits (upholding statutory grant of authority under SDCL 9-32-8 for cities to protect water supplies “within one mile of the limits of the municipality.”)  This decision is unanimous with opinion authored by Justice Salter.

This decision may be accessed at

 

http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .

 

 

 

Thursday, August 20, 2020

Two Criminal Cases decided today; Convictions Affirmed by SD Supreme Court

 The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning, holding inter alia: 

1)    2nd degree rape conviction affirmed; 

2)   Aggravated and simple assault convictions affirmed.


Summaries follow:

STATE v. TAYLOR, 2020 S.D. 48:  Defendant was sentenced to 50 years in prison with 20 years suspended following jury conviction of 2nd degree rape.  The SD Supreme Court affirmed, rejecting numerous assertions of error (“1. Whether the circuit court abused its discretion by allowing evidence of Taylor’s two prior alleged sexual assaults. 2. Whether the admission of the other act evidence violated Taylor’s constitutional rights under the Double Jeopardy and Due Process Clauses. 3. Whether the circuit court abused its discretion when it denied Taylor’s motion for a mistrial. 4. Whether the circuit court erred when it denied Taylor’s motion for a judgment of acquittal. 5. Whether the circuit court’s admission of the forensic laboratory reports by affidavit under SDCL 23-3-19.3 resulted in prejudicial error. 6. Whether Taylor’s sentence violates the Eighth Amendment”).  This decision is unanimous with opinion authored by Justice Jensen.

 

STATE v. BRYANT, 2020 S.D. 49:  Criminal defendant, having been found guilty by jury of multiple counts of aggravated and simple assault, was sentenced to 12 years in prison, with 3 years suspended and he was also ordered to pay Medicaid $31,246.69 as restitution for the victim’s  medical expenses.  The SD Supreme Court affirmed.  This decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Kern.

 

These decisions may be accessed at

 

http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .

 

Thursday, August 13, 2020

Two Decisions this Morning by SD Supreme Court

 

The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning:

1)    Wife prevails in contempt proceeding against ex-Husband;

2)   State of South Dakota denied recovery of clean-up funds related to underground oil tanks

 

Summaries follows:

 

FARMER v. FARMER, 2020 S.D. 46:  Wife brought this contempt proceeding against ex-Husband for the purpose of enforcing property settlement agreement incorporated into 2014 divorce decree.  Trial court found ex-Husband in contempt and that he owed Wife $331,184.81.  Trial court further held, “To satisfy this debt and purge himself of contempt, [ex-Husband is] ordered [to] convey to [wife] his membership interests in certain entities and his ownership interest in certain properties."  Trial court also awarded Wife attorney fees.  The SD Supreme Court affirmed, awarding Wife additional appellate attorney fees of $29,172.62, the full amount of Wife’s request.  This decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice DeVaney.  The contempt proceeding was initiated in the trial court in 2016, but not finally resolved until August, 2018, with numerous hearings held in the interim.

S.D. PETROLEUM RELEASE COMPENSATION FUND v. BP, 2020 S.D. 47: The State of South Dakota sought recovery of clean-up funds related to “environmental contamination from underground petroleum storage tanks” at 27 locations in South Dakota.  The trial court denied recovery to the State and the SD Supreme Court affirmed.  The first 2 paragraphs of the opinion explain this litigation and result as follows:

[¶1.] The State of South Dakota and the South Dakota Petroleum Release Compensation Fund (Fund) sought to recover payments made to the predecessor and subsidiary companies of BP plc (hereafter jointly referred to as “BP”) for the costs of cleaning up environmental contamination from underground petroleum storage tanks (UST) at 27 BP sites in South Dakota.1 The Fund also sought to recover payments made to third parties for cleanup costs at 19 other UST sites in South Dakota. The Fund referred to these latter claims as “indirect claims,” alleging that BP was responsible for cleanup costs because it had previously owned or operated the USTs at the 19 sites. 

[¶2.] The circuit court initially granted BP’s motion for summary judgment on all but one of the 19 indirect claims, determining the claims were time-barred by the applicable statute of limitations. Later, the circuit court granted BP’s motion for summary judgment on the Fund’s remaining claims against BP. The Fund appeals, arguing that the circuit court erred in dismissing its claims. The Fund also argues the circuit court abused its discretion in denying its motion for discovery sanctions. We affirm.

This decision is unanimous (5-0) with opinion authored by Justice Jensen.  Circuit Judge Sabers sat on this case, in lieu of Justice DeVaney who was the trial judge. 

These decisions may be accessed at

http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .

 

Thursday, July 30, 2020

Three new decisions by the SD Supreme Court today


The SD Supreme Court handed down three decisions this morning:
1)    Public Duty rule prohibits suit against City of Sioux Falls;
2)   Denial of Motion to Suppress upheld (Sturgis Rally Conviction);
3)   Dispute over tenancy in common/joint tenancy issue following death of wife.

Summaries follows:

FODNESS v. CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, 2020 S.D. 43:  Personal injury victim sustained injuries when her apartment collapsed as a result of a contractor’s work.  This action was filed against the City of Sioux Falls, asserting negligence in the issuance of a building permit for the contractor.  The trial court dismissed the action on the basis of the public duty rule.  The SD Supreme Court affirmed, observing that the, “complaint failed to plead facts sufficient to establish... the special duty exception to the public duty rule” as recognized in Tipton v. Town of Tabor (Tipton I), 538 N.W.2d 783 (S.D. 1995).  This decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Kern.  Circuit Judge Means sat on this case, in lieu of Justice Salter.


STATE v. WILLIAMS, 2020 S.D. 44:  Defendant was convicted of various offenses arising out of an arrest around 2:00 A.M. made during the 2018 Sturgis Rally.  Officers detained the Defendant after observing what appeared to be a drawn weapon with a red laser light pointed at the Oasis Bar.  The trial court suspended imposition of sentence on the offenses and placed Defendant on unsupervised probation for one year.   Defendant appeals the denial of his Motion to Suppress.  The SD Supreme Court affirmed.  This decision is unanimous with opinion authored by Justice Kern. 

MOECKLY v. HANSON, 2020 S.D. 45: This proceeding is summarized in ¶ 1 of the Court’s opinion as follows:

Personal representatives for the estate of Sharon Orr-Hanson brought a partition action for property owned by Sharon and her husband, Bennet Hanson. The circuit court held the property was owned as tenants in common and ordered partition. Hanson appeals, arguing the property was held as joint tenants and should go to him alone as the surviving joint tenant. We affirm.

The Court’s decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Chief Justice Gilbertson. 

These decisions may be accessed at



Thursday, July 23, 2020

One Decision from SD Supreme Court today


The SD Supreme Court handed down one decision this morning, holding inter alia:  

1)    90 year sentence imposed upon 17 year old defendant affirmed

Summary follows:

STATE v. QUEVEDO, 2020 S.D. 42:  The trial court’s sentence, imposed after a guilty plea to 2nd degree murder is upheld notwithstanding the young age of the Defendant at the time of the offense.  The trial court’s action and the SD Supreme Court’s ruling is summarily stated in ¶¶ 1 & 42 as follows:

[¶1] Carlos Quevedo pled guilty to second-degree murder in the stabbing death of Kasie Lord. He was 17 years old when he committed the crime. The circuit court sentenced him to 90 years in prison, making him eligible for parole at age 62. Quevedo appeals, claiming his sentence is unconstitutional because it violates categorical limitations placed upon sentences for juveniles and because it is disproportionately harsh. We affirm.   

[¶42] Quevedo’s 90-year discretionary sentence does not offend the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, either as a categorically prohibited mandatory life sentence or as a sentence that is disproportionate to the offense. We affirm.   

The Court’s decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Salter.
   
This decision may be accessed at