Thursday, September 10, 2020

SD Supreme Court hands down 1 decision today

 

The SD Supreme Court handed down one decision this morning, holding inter alia:  

 

1)    Divorce court reversed for setting aside “partially gifted” land in favor of H

 Summary follows: 

FIELD v. FIELD, 2020 S.D. 51:  During their marriage, H & W received farmland from H's relative at significantly discounted purchase price.  In this divorce proceeding, the trial court treated the transfer as a "partial gift" made solely to H.  The SD Supreme Court reversed and remanded, holding that, “entire value of the [farmland] should be subject to equitable division.”  This opinion confirms that existing SD rule the grant of an interest in real estate jointly to both H & W, “can be convincing evidence of the realty's status as marital property,” and it also recognizes, "that spouses can provide valuable contributions to the acquisition and maintenance of inherited or gifted property by acting as homemakers or working separately to assist the other spouse in maintaining inherited or gifted property." 

This decision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Salter.

This decision may be accessed at

 http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .