Thursday, April 9, 2026
City Park in Spearfish, subject of litigation
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) City of Spearfish dealt a blow in dispute over asserted public roadway across city park.,
Summary follows:
TURGEON v. CITY OF SPEARFISH, 2026 S.D. 22: Landowners in Spearfish claim they need access across the Thone Stone Monument property owned by City of Sturgis and operated as a City Park. Landowners claim that the road on this park property provides their only access to the real estate. Landowners filed suit for a Declaratory Judgment that the park road was a road which had been dedicated to the public, relying, inter alia, on a plat which was recorded in 2012 which stated that the road was dedicated to the public. The City was using a locked gate across the road to block access. The trial court granted summary judgment for the City, holding that the 2012 plat language had never been officially accepted by the City. The trial court rejected landowners arguments that the City had expressly accepted the dedication and, alternatively that the City had implicitly accepted the dedication, stating:
[¶40.] However, in determining whether there was an implied acceptance of the dedication, the circuit court failed to consider logical inferences from the facts and the court inappropriately weighed the competing evidence regarding this issue. We, therefore, reverse the circuit court’s decision granting the City’s motion for summary judgment and remand the case for trial on the question of whether there was an implied acceptance of the 2012 dedication by the City.
The matter is reversed and remanded for trial on the issue of implied acceptance.
This decision is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Retired Justice Kern.
NOTE: Information about this historical Monument is provided
In ¶3 of the opinion, as follows: “The Thoen Stone was discovered on Lookout Mountain in 1887. It recounts the story of gold prospectors who traveled to the Black Hills in search of gold in 1834, forty years before the Black Hills Gold Rush. A replica of the Thoen Stone, the Thoen Stone Monument, now sits at the end of St. Joe Street in Spearfish and is accessible via the Road.”
And in footnote 1 of the opinion as follows: “Although not contained in the record, the following information is of significant historical interest. The stone slab, dated 1834, recounts the story of Ezra Kind and his companions who traveled to the Black Hills in search of gold. The marker calls into question the date of the first discovery of gold in the Black Hills, which was previously thought to be 1874 after the Custer Expedition and the subsequent gold rush. The stone, which was buried several feet below the surface, was discovered in 1887 by Louis Thoen on Lookout Mountain in Spearfish. The original stone is located in the Adams Museum and House in Deadwood. The replica sits above Spearfish at the end of the Thoen Stone Road east of town.”
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, April 2, 2026
Grand Theft and Conspiracy Convictions Reversed
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Convictions for Grand Theft and Conspiracy Reversed
Summary follows:
STATE v. SPRY, 2026 S.D. 21: Husband and Wife (H & W) were charged with handling matters for Uncle, by virtue of a Power of Attorney. After Uncle died intestate, H & W transferred funds from a joint bank account (for all three) into their separate account. This criminal prosecution was institute at the urging of an attorney for “concerned relatives.” After a 3-day Jury trial in Bon Homme County, H & W were both convicted of some misdemeanor charges but also convicted of Grand Theft and Conspiracy to Commit Grand Theft. In ruling on joint appeals, the SD Supreme Court reversed and remanded the Grand Theft and Conspiracy to Commit Grand Theft convictions. The reversal is based upon evidentiary error and error in the jury instructions, as stated by the Court:
[¶45.] [T]he court erred by not admitting Way’s [Susan Was was an agent of H & W who witnessed Uncle’s execution of documents] testimony of [Uncle’s] contemporaneous out-of-court statements under SDCL 19-19-803(3). We further conclude that the circuit court erred when instructing the jury on the burden of proof the State must meet to rebut the presumption that [Uncle] intended the [H & W] to have rights of survivorship with respect to the funds remaining in the joint bank account. Accordingly, we reverse the grand theft and conspiracy to commit grand theft convictions and remand for further proceedings.
This decision is unanimous (5-0) by the Court, with opinion authored by Justice Kern.
NOTE: Relatives also sued H & W in federal court in a civil action which prompted a decision by the SD Supreme Court in Matter of Certification of Question of Law from United States District Court, District of South Dakota, 2022 S.D. 60, 981 N.W.2d 325.
NOTE also: The successful attorney in this case is former student John Hinrichs who also served as Magistrate Judge in the 2nd Circuit for 9 years, 2006-2017. Congratulations John!
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, March 19, 2026
Inmate's misconduct results in 2 more years to term of imprisonment
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Inmate’s misconduct adds 2 years to his term of imprisonment
Summary follows:
STATE v. WARFIELD, 2026 S.D. 20: Incident occurred at Mike Durfee State Prison in Springfield. Inmate was charged with two counts of assault and 1 count of intentional damage to property. Video surveillance was used as part of the State’s evidence, but there was an issue as to its completeness. Jury convicted inmate of 1 count of assault and of intentional damage to property. Inmate was acquitted on other count of assault. The trial court sentenced Inmate to 2 years to run consecutive to his other sentences and ordered restitution and court costs. The SD Supreme Court affirmed. This decision is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Gusinski. This case was submitted on the briefs 5 weeks, 2 days ago.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, March 12, 2026
Four new Decisions by SD Supreme Court today
The SD Supreme Court handed down 4 decisions this morning:
1) hearsay phone call to police permissible as cumulative/corrobative;
2) immunity from civil assault found in self-defense statute;
3) Six appeals (consolidated) from Meade and Lawrence County result in affirmance of prison sentences;
4) convictions for failure to appear and assault affirmed, rejecting jurisdictional challenge related to Indian Country issue.
Summaries follow:
STATE v. CLIFFORD, 2026 S.D. 16: Following a family dispute April 6, 2023, Defendant took a drive, resulting in his arrest. Thereafter he was convicted by jury of “aggravated eluding, reckless driving, driving under suspension, and failing to stop at a stop sign.” As part of its case, the State introduced evidence of a phone call to the police alerting as to Defendant being on the roadway. Defendant asserts on appeal that this evidence was inadmissible hearsay. The SD Supreme Court rejected this argument and affirmed, holding that the phone call evidence was “merely cumulative or corroborative of other evidence that was independently and properly admitted.” This decision is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Kern.
ANDERSON v. STREETER, 2026 S.D. 17: Defendant shot Plaintiff in the chest. Grand Jury considered the facts, but failed to indict. Plaintiff filed this Civil Suit for Assault. The trial court ruled for Defendant holding that he was immune from civil liability because he acted in self-defense, pursuant to SDCL 22-18-4.8 (which grants immunity from both criminal prosecution and civil liability). Plaintiff appeals. The SD Supreme Court affirmed in a unanimous (5-0) ruling, with opinion authored by Justice Myrne. Circuit Judge Klinger on this case, in lieu of Justice Gusinsky who had served as the trial judge. Defendant requested appellate attorney fees, but the Court denied the request, noting that attorney fees were awardable by the trial court under to SDCL 22-18-4.8 and, therefore, also awardable on appeal. But, the Court denied the request because Defendant had “not submitted a motion or a ‘verified, itemized statement of legal services rendered,’ as required by SDCL 15-26A-87.3(1).”
STATE v. WARE, 2026 S.D. 18: Defendant, whose “criminal history is extensive,” entered guilty pleas to three felony charges in Lawrence County, as well as to a felony charge in Meade County. He was sentenced to prison, with the Meade County sentence to run consecutive to the Lawrence County sentence. The SD Supreme Court consolidated six (6) differnt appeals by the Defendant, but grants no relief to Defendant, affirming the lower courts. The Court’s ruling is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Gusinsky.
STATE v. WINCKLER, 2026 S.D. 19: Defendant was convicted by Jury of “failing to appear for a pretrial conference at the Charles Mix County courthouse,” and also entered a guilty plea to “a separate, unrelated criminal matter, the crime of simple assault after an altercation with another inmate at the Charles Mix County jail.” Defendant appeals both proceedings. Defendant argues, inter alia, a jurisdictional issue, “alleg[ing] that the Charles Mix County courthouse and jail are situated in Indian country, thus depriving the State of subject matter jurisdiction over [him], an enrolled member of the Yankton Sioux Tribe.” The SD Supreme Court disposes of both appeals with this decision. The Court affirms in both, and rejects the jurisdictional argument. The Court also affirming on other issues raised. The Court’s opinion is authored by Justice Gusinsky. All five justices agree on the result. Justice Salter filed a concurring opinion, casting doubt on the reliability of existing precedent (Bruguier v. Class, 1999 S.D. 122, 599 N.W.2d 364) in regard to the jurisdictional analysis.
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, March 5, 2026
Four New Decisions Today
The SD Supreme Court handed down 4 decisionsthis morning:
1) transgender woman denied amended birthcertificate;
2) doctrine of judicial estoppel endsone part of family dispute over land;
3) DOT employees shielded from law suit;
4) Rule 11 sanctions availableagainst client.
Summaries follow:
AMENDED BIRTH CERTIFICATE OF NIELSEN, 2026 S.D.12: Transgender woman sought to amend official birth certificate, so as “to change the sex designation from male to femaleto reflect her current gender identity.” The trialcourt denied relief. The SD Supreme Courtaffirmed the denial of relief. All fivejustices voted to affirm. The Court’s opinionis authored by Justice DeVaney. JusticeSalter filed a concurring opinion in which he specifically endorses a concurringopinion by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Alita in a recent decision, [UnitedStates v. Skrmetti, 605 U.S. 495, 559 (2025)]. Chief Justice Jensen endorsed Justice Salter’sconcurring opinion (endorsing Justice Alito). Newly appointed Justice Gusinsky did not participate in this case.
BRYANT v. BRYANT, 2026 S.D. 13: Two brothers areinvolved in litigation against each other and also their mother. The Father isdeceased and divorced from the Mother prior to his death. The trial court held that the brothers heldtitle jointly, but that Mother’s claim is barred by judicialestoppel. Noting that a partitionaction involving the brothers is still pending, Mother appeals under SDCL15-6-54(b). The SD Supreme Court acceptedthe appeal and affirmed. This decisionis unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Chief Justice Jensen. This casewas submitted to the Court less than a month ago, on January 10, 2026.
ESTATE OF SANBORN v. PETERSON, ET AL, 2026 S.D.14: Two girls died in a motor vehicle accident on SD Highway 218. Claiming that “that the fatal accident resulted from the DOTemployees’ negligent failure to maintain and repair the adjacent gravelshoulder in compliance with governing standards,” Mother of the girls filed suitagainst six DOT employees. The trialcourt granted summary judgment for Defendants on the basis of the “public duty doctrine.” The SD Supreme Court affirmed but did so onthe basis of “sovereign immunity,” not “public duty.” The SDSupreme Court’s opinion is authored by Justice Salter, with two Justices infull agreement. Chief Justice Jensen filed a brief concurring opinion. Retired Justice Kern filed a dissenting opinionin which she asserts the duty imposed on Defendants is a “ministerial duty,” not a “discretionary duty.” Justice Kern’s dissent containscolor photographs depicting an unacceptable drop-off of up to 7 inches in theshoulder.
DISSOLUTION OF HEALY RANCH, INC., 2026 S.D. 15: This litigation is seeminglynever-ending. In this chapter, the issueis a $240,000 sanction imposed on a litigant under Rule 11. The SD Supreme Court reverses and “remand[s]for a hearing and reconsideration of the various types of sanctions, and if amonetary sanction is imposed, a determination that includes Bret’s ability topay the monetary sanction.” This is a 3-2 decision, with the Court’s opinion authoredby Retired Justice Kern. Justice Salterfiles a concurring opinion expressing the belief that monetary sanctions, whilepermissible against an attorney representing a client, are not permissibleagainst a client/litigant only. Justice DeVaneyconcurs with Justice Salter. NOTE: TheLitigant perfected his appeal in this matter pro se.
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, February 26, 2026
Minor committed to DOC for terroristic threat at Edgemont School
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Terroristic Threat at school warrants commitment of minor to DOC,
Summary follows:
INTEREST OF J.A.D., III, 2026 S.D. 11: Student at Edgemont School threatened to go home, get a gun and “threatened to shoot a school counselor, other students, and himself.” Brave and wise Special Ed teacher (my words here) sought to help the student when he wanted to leave school, interviewed the student, and then took action and called 911, resulting in a “soft lockdown” and intervention by law enforcement. In a juvenile delinquency proceeding, the State charged the student with “(1) aggravated assault; (2) simple assault; and (3) making a terrorist threat.” The trial court found that the State did not establish (1) aggravated assault, but that the State did establish (2) simple assault and (3) terroristic threat. Trial Court committed the Student to DOC. Student appealed. The SD Supreme Court vacated the (2) simple assault adjudication, but affirmed the (3) terroristic threat adjudication. The Court also affirmed that trial court’s decision to commit the student to DOC. The Court’s opinion is authored by Justice Myren, with 3 other justices in full agreement. Justice Salter filed a separate opinion in which he expresses the view that the (2) simply assault adjudication should also be upheld.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, February 19, 2026
Three new Decisions today by SD Supreme Court
TheSD Supreme Court handed down three decisions this morning:
1) compensable damages, condemnationaction;
2) calculation of restitution reversed;
3) Trial court’s award of Rule11 sanctions reversed.
Summariesfollow:
DEP'TOF TRANSPORTATION v. GUSTAFSON, 2026 S.D. 8: This suit addresses the question of exactly what is compensable in acondemnation action. The property inquestion is around one of the most well-known intersections in South Dakota –I-29 and 41st Street in Sioux Falls. After a determination and payment “compensation for the fair value of the parts of their propertytaken for a permanent easement and a temporary construction easement.” Actual construction associatedwith this project, “also provided for theclosure of the 41st Street and Carolyn Avenue intersection, which eliminatedthe shortest indirect access route to the [landowners'] property from 41stStreet.” Landowners sought additional compensation forthis “loss of access.” The State said no. The trial court held that, “that the closure of this intersectionsubstantially impaired their right of access, and that they sustained an injurypeculiar to their property.” In a split decision (3-2) among the Justices,the Supreme Court reversed. The Court’sdecision, (which runs 38 pages and 58 ¶ s), is authored by Justice DeVaney,with Chief Justice Jensen and Justice Salter in full agreement. Retired Justice Kern filed a dissenting opinion,agreed to by Justice Myren. The Dissent would, “affirm the circuitcourt’s order and remand for entry of the stipulated award of $1,329,389, plusinterests and costs, for a total of $1,510,901.”
STATEv. JANES, 2026 S.D. 9: Defendant appeals his conviction for child abuse or crueltyof a minor, his stepchild. On appealDefendant raises 4 issues related to Evidentiary rulings, in addition to abusein sentencing and the determination of restitution. He also raises ineffective assistance of counsel.The SD Supreme Court rejects all of Defendant’s arguments, except for thecalculation of restitution related to “the children’s counseling expenses” and remanded for re-evaluation.The Court’s decision is unanimous (5-0) with opinion authored by Chief JusticeJensen.
WELLSFARGO v. MYERS, 2026 S.D. 10: This is adebt collection action against “Mary Myers.” There are at least two individuals withthe name “Mary Myers.” The Sheriff served “Mary 2,” not “Mary 1” who would have beenthe correct party. Attorney for Mary 2contacted Plaintiff’s counsel seeking a dismissal. When the dismissal was not forthcoming, Mary2 sought rule 11 sanctions which the trial judge awarded in the amount of “$3,662.93 [for Mary 2’s] attorney fees.” The SD Supreme Court reversed findingthat “conduct was notsanctionable under [the] Rule.” (The opinion contains a detailed recitationof the relevant events.) The Court’sdecision is unanimous, with opinion authored by Justice Myren. Justice Salter filed a concurring opinion.
Thesedecisions may be accessed at http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, February 12, 2026
8th Circuit Hands Down two D.S.D. decisions today
The Johnson appeal, the reversal, is from the Southern Division.
The Cadotte appeal, a per curiam dismissal of appeal, is from the Western Division, Hon. Karen E. Schreier.
U.S. v Johnson: Defendant filed a Motion to Suppress evidence on the basis that the routine traffic stop was prolonged beyond a reasonable time, with the detaining officer waiting for a drug dog. Following the trial court's denial of the motion to suppress, Defendant pled guilty to a federal drug offense. The 8th Circuit reversed and vacated the conviction. The Court's opinion, authored by Judge Kobes states:
[The] Officer prolonged the stop beyond the time needed to address Johnson’s traffic violations. Cf. Peralez, 526 F.3d at 1120 (officer’s “drug interdiction questions,” interspersed with “routine processing of a traffic stop,” unreasonably prolonged the stop). In his own words, it normally takes him five or six minutes to complete and explain a traffic ticket. So if he had diligently written the window tint warning, he would have completed it by 20 minutes and 42 seconds into the stop at the latest and Johnson would have been free to go before the K9 arrived.
This is a split decision (2-1), with a dissenting opinion by Judge Stras.
U.S. v Cadotte: Defendant pled guilty to child porn and was sentenced 240 months, followed by 5 years of supervised release. The plea agreement contained an "appeal waiver." Nonetheless, Defendant appealed. The 8th Circuit dismissed the appeal, upholding the appeal waiver. This is a per curiam decision and there is no discussion of an examination of the record for other grounds for relief and no indication of an Anders brief.
These decisions may be accessed by clicking on the links below:
Current Opinions are for Thursday, February 12, 2026
213954P.pdf 02/12/2026 United States v. Alex Johnson
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 21-3954
U.S. District Court for the District of South Dakota - Southern
242625U.pdf 02/12/2026 United States v. Tell Cadotte
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 24-2625
U.S. District Court for the District of South Dakota - Western
Thursday, February 5, 2026
Three Reversals
The SD Supreme Court handed down three decisions this morning:
1) Defense verdict in personal injury action reversed;
2) 2nd ruling for liability insurer reversed;
3) Expert on “false confessions” rejected.
Summaries follows:
HAMER v. DUFFY, CORNERSTONE POURED FOUNDATIONS, INC., 2026 S.D. 4: This is a personal injury action arising out of an automobile accident. The jury ruled against the plaintiffs. The SD Supreme Court reversed, holding that the trial judge committed several errors: 1) error to exclude the testimony of two expert witnesses tendered by Plaintiffs; 2) error in denying Plaintiffs’ motion to amend their complaint to “to assert violations of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations [as set forth at] 49 C.F.R. § 392.3”; 3) error to not instruct jury in regard to of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations. This decision is unanimous (5-0), with opinion by Justice DeVaney
KAISER TRUCKING, INC. v. LIBERTY MUTUAL, 2026 S.D. 5: In this case the tortfeasor’s liability insurer is contesting coverage. In a previous appeal, the SD Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s grant of summary judgment for the insurer. Kaiser Trucking, Inc. v. Liberty Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 2022 S.D. 64, 981 N.W.2d 645. On remand, the trial court once again granted summary judgment for the liability insurer. Once again, the SD Supreme Court reverses. This decision is unanimous (5-0), with opinion by Justice DeVaney.
STATE v. HUANTE, 2026 S.D. 6: This is a 1st degree murder prosecution in Rapid City. The Defendant finally gave a confession, after being told that he failed his polygraph and that the investigators “knew” he shot the victim. The Defense claimed a “false confession” and put forward an expert witness to provide testimony on false confessions. The trial court ruled that the “false confessions expert” would be allowed to testify. The State took an intermediate appeal to the SD Supreme Court which reversed the trial judge’s decision. The Supreme Court’s ruling is a (4-1) decision with the majority opinion authored by Justice Salter on reassignment. Justice Myren filed a dissenting opinion in which he states:
[¶90.] In my view, the majority opinion requires [the Defense] to satisfy a standard that is more demanding than Daubert requires and does not apply the appropriate level of deference required by the abuse of discretion standard of review applicable to this case.
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, January 29, 2026
Med Mal Action Reinstated by SD Supreme Court
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Plaintiffs’ malpractice action reinstated,
Summary follows:
WALTON v. HURON REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, 2026 S.D. 3: This is a medical malpractice action filed against a Doctor and also Huron Regional Medical Center. The patient, having been previously diagnosed with Guillain-Barré syndrome, filed this action claiming that he “suffered a hypoxic brain injury from the administration of high dosages of opiates and the failure to properly monitor him while being treated for testicular pain.” His wife joined as co-plaintiff. Plaintiffs relied on a report. Plaintiff relied on the proposed testimony of Dr. Adler, serving as a “causation expert.” The trial court granted Defendants’ Motion to Exclude the testimony of Dr. Adler and then granted Defendants Summary Judgment. The SD Supreme Court reversed, holding as follows:
[¶52.] [T]he circuit court abused its discretion in excluding his opinions. In particular, the court failed to apply the Daubert reliability standards to the differential diagnosis methodology, including all of the information and data relied upon by Dr. Adler, to arrive at his opinions. “When a trial court misapplies a rule of evidence, as opposed to merely allowing or refusing questionable evidence, it abuses its discretion.” Guthrie, 2001 S.D. 61, ¶ 30, 627 N.W.2d at 415 (citation omitted). We reverse the circuit court’s decision excluding Dr. Adler’s opinions and testimony, including the qEEG evidence.
This decision is unanimous (5-0) with opinion authored by Chief Justice Jensen.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, January 15, 2026
Prenuptial Agreement Upheld
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Prenuptial Agreement Upheld,
Summary follows:
ESTATE OF WEBB, 2026 S.D. 2: At the ages of 57 and 29, prospective H & W executed a prenuptial agreement, “after dating for nearly a year.” In the agreement, “[W] waived right to claim any share of [H's] estate after his death.” The marriage was conducted at an attorney’s office in Faith, SD, in the aftermath of the Atlas Blizzard on October 11, 2013. The prenuptial agreement was signed shortly before the civil ceremony. Upon H’s death 8 years later, W sought an elective share of his estate and also a family allowance. The trial court granted W a family allowance but denied her request for an elective share, upholding the prenuptial agreement. The SD Supreme Court affirmed. The Court’s opinion is authored by Retired Justice Kern. Justice Salter filed a brief opinion, concurring in result but also dissenting in part.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, January 8, 2026
Improper use of Collateral Estoppel warrants reversal and new trial
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Improper use of Collateral Estoppel warrants reversal and new trial,
Summary follows:
ESTATE OF O'NEILL, 2026 S.D. 1: Son sought probate of his mother’s last Will which gave him the entire estate, to the exclusion of his siblings. Siblings alleged “undue influence.” The trial court relied upon findings in a civil dispute between Son and a brother, for the purpose of narrowing the jury’s consideration of the issues, resulting in an adverse verdict for Son. Son appeals. The SD Supreme Court reversed and remanded, stating:
[¶42.] The circuit court erred in wholesale admitting findings of fact and conclusions of law regarding issues that were not identical to issues in the resent case and not necessary or essential to the prior judgment. By then instructing the jury that all of the findings—including credibility determinations and specific statements that Tony had been dishonest with Rick and the court—and instructing the jury to consider those findings and conclusions as established, the court effectively foreclosed the jury’s ability to undertake its own independent assessment of the witnesses’ credibility on the issues more closely connected to the Respondents’ undue influence claim. We reverse and remand for a new trial.
This ruling is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Salter. This scholarly opinion presents a thorough discussion of the doctrine of “Collateral estoppel, also known as issue preclusion,” as it has evolved in South Dakota.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Wednesday, December 31, 2025
referral fee dispute regarding accounting services for credit cards
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. My summary is set forth below.
1) Dispute regarding referral fee for accounting services for credit cards;
Summary follows:
LJP CONSULTING, LLC v. VERVENT, INC., 2025 S.D. 74: This dispute involves accounting services for the servicing of credit card accounts. In particular, this dispute involves the payment of referral fees in regard to the accounts referred to Defendant’s predecessor in title by Plaintiff and whether Defendant was/is required to continue to make the referral fee payments. A jury determined that Defendant was liable for payment of “$1,000,064.75 for unpaid referral fees.” The trial judge then entered a permanent injunction in regard to payment of future fees. The SD Supreme Court lowered the damage award and reversed and vacated the permanent injunction, stating:
[¶48.] We affirm the circuit court’s determination that the Referral Agreement was not terminable at the will of Vervent. We reverse the court’s denial of Vervent’s Rule 50 motions for judgment as a matter of law and vacate the circuit court’s final judgment and order granting a permanent injunction. We remand for the entry of a judgment determining, as a matter of law, that Vervent’s liability for referral fees ended after it acquired First Equity and amending the damages award accordingly.
This ruling is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice DeVaney.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Tuesday, December 23, 2025
Two New Decisions by the SD Supreme Court this morning
The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning:
1) Summary Judgment for Defendants affirmed in dispute over purchase agreement;
2) False Report Conviction reinstated over fabricated false breath test;
Summaries follow:
TRIGGER ENERGY HOLDINGS v. STEVENS, 2025 S.D. 72: Plaintiffs sued to reform a purchase agreement which they had signed, asserting theories of economic duress, fiduciary duty breaches and other torts. The agreement related to the sale of Plaintiffs’ interests in one corporate LLC to another corporate LLC – both of which are named Defendants herein, together with an individual co-Defendant. The trial court granted summary judgment for Defendants. The SD Supreme Court affirmed. This is a unanimous ruling (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Salter.
STATE v. BITELER, 2025 S.D. 73: This case involves an individual, on probation for DUI, required, as a condition of probation, to provide breathalyzer tests remotely through a remote testing device. This device takes a photo of the person submitting the sample. The deputy sheriff overseeing the 24/7 program detected photo “manipulation” in the Defendant’s submitted samples – meaning the breath test was given by another person with the wrong photo. Defendant was charged with 6 counts of false reporting under SDCL 22-11-9(3). The Magistrate Judge convicted Defendant of 1 of the 6 counts and acquitted the Defendant of the other 5 counts. Defendant appealed to the Circuit Court which reversed the one conviction based upon its interpretation of “report” as found in the statute. The State appealed. The SD Supreme Court reversed the Circuit Court and reinstated the Magistrate Judge’s conviction. All five Justices agree on this result. The Court’s opinion is authored by Justice Myren, with two Justices in full concurrence. Justice Salter provided a special concurring opinion, in which Retired Justice Kern concurred. NOTE: this case was orally argued just a month ago, on November 17, 2025.
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, December 18, 2025
Two new SD Supreme Court Decisions today
The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning:
1) dismissal for failure to prosecute reversed;
2) visitation rights ruling affirmed;
Summaries follows:
ARROWSMITH v. ODLE, 2025 S.D. 70: The trial court dismissed this personal injury action on the basis of failure to prosecute. The SD Supreme Court reversed, stating:
[¶34.] Under the circumstances, we conclude the circuit court abused its discretion in granting [Defendant's] motion to dismiss for failure to prosecute under both SDCL 15-11-11 and Rule 41(b) and remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
This ruling is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Retired Justice Kern.
JESSOP v. COMBS, 2025 S.D. 71: In this visitation dispute, Mother requested that Father be granted only supervised visitation. Trial court granted Father unsupervised visitation, in accordance with SD’s Parenting Guidelines. Mother appealed. The SD Supreme Court affirmed, deferring to the trial court. And, because Mother did not prevail on any issue on appeal, her request for appellate attorneys was denied. This ruling is unanimous (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Salter.
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Friday, December 12, 2025
TODAY: 8th Circuit Upholds D.S.D. (District of South Dakota) X 2
NORTHERN Division:
Brendan LaBatte v. Karen Gangle: This lawsuit challenges the assertion of jurisdiction in the tribal court for the Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate Sioux Tribe, challenging the court's authority to entertain a DUI charge -- a charge which, although initially filed in tribal court, was subsequently dismissed without prejudice. The named Defendants were, "Karen Gangle, Prosecutor for the SWO, in their official capacity; Gary Gaikowski, Chief of Police for SWO, in their official capacity; Hon. Ruth Burns, Judge for the SWO Tribal Court, in their official capacity; Hon. Michael Swallow, Judge for the SWO Tribal Court, in their official capacity." The trial judge, Hon. Eric C. Schulte, dismissed for lack of federal subject matter jurisdiction. This 11 page opinion by the 8th Circuit, heavily laden with discussions of Indian Soverreignty, Federal Jurisdiction and Mootness, upholds the trial court's ruling, clarifying as follows:
"[T]his case must be dismissed. We affirm the judgment of the district court, vacate the court’s decision, and therefore need not decide the jurisdiction, sovereign immunity, and tribal court exhaustion issues the parties have briefed and argued. See Madore, 128 F.4th at 942-43."
WESTERN Division:
Daniel Lipsky v. Nate Cronin: This is a pro se 1983 civil rights claim filed against, "Nate Cronin; Bill Wainman; Michael Close; City of Hot Springs, SD." The trial judge, Hon. Lawrence L. Piersol, dismissed the complaint, partially sustaining a Motion to Dismiss and dismissing the remaining claims by way of Summary Judgment. The 8th Circuit affirmed in a brief one-paragraph per curiam opinion.
These opinions may be viewed by clicking on the links below:
Current Opinions are for Friday, December 12, 2025
242798P.pdf 12/12/2025 Brendan LaBatte v. Karen Gangle
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 24-2798
U.S. District Court for the District of South Dakota - Northern
251692U.pdf 12/12/2025 Daniel Lipsky v. Nate Cronin
U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 25-1692
U.S. District Court for the District of South Dakota - Western
Thursday, December 11, 2025
Criminal Convictions Upheld
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Criminal convictions upheld;
Summary follows:
STATE v. LONG, 2025 S.D. 69: This is a criminal appeal, aptly described in the opening paragraph as follows:
[¶1.] Lance Long was convicted in Corson County of three counts of rape, three counts of aggravated assault, and five counts of abuse of or cruelty to a minor. The victims were Long’s stepchildren. Other act evidence of similar conduct by Long involving these same children was admitted at trial over Long’s objection. The circuit court denied Long’s motion for judgment of acquittal regarding one of the rape counts. Long appeals his convictions, and we affirm.
This is a unanimous decision (5-0), with opinion authored by Justice Myren.
NOTE: In this opinion, Justice Kern is shown as participating as a “Retired Justice.” Justice Gusinski is shown as “not participating. This is the first time I have seen Justice Gusinski’s name on an opinion as a Supreme Court Justice. 😊
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Wednesday, November 26, 2025
Theft by Exploitation
The SD Supreme Court handed down 1 new decision this morning. Summary is set forth below.
1) Multiple Convictions of “theft by exploitation” upheld.
Summary follows:
STATE v. CLEMENSEN, 2025 S.D. 68: Defendant was found guilty, by jury, of 7 Counts of theft/fraud related charges (“theft by exploitation”) in regard to the misappropriation of more than $500,000 from his mother. Upon receipt of an inquiry initiated by a grandson of the victim, the South Dakota DCI conducted an intensive investigation and caused these charges to be filed. Following the jury convictions, the trial court imposed “fully suspended” prison sentences (of unspecified lengths) and placed Defendant on probation. This appeal follows, with Defendant asserting, “the State failed to present sufficient evidence to prove the elements of the crimes charged… [and that] the circuit court failed to properly instruct the jury regarding his good faith defense.” The SD Supreme Court affirmed in a unanimous (5-0) decision, with opinion authored by Justice DeVaney. This opinion runs 26 pages.
This decision may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, November 20, 2025
Two New Decisions today by SD Supreme Court
The SD Supreme Court handed down two decisions this morning:
1) Award of attorney fees to landowner in condemnation proceeding upheld;
2) H loses appeal on property division ruling and ordered to pay W attorney fees;
Summaries follow:
CITY OF SIOUX FALLS v. JOHNSON PROPERTIES, 2025 S.D. 66: This is a condemnation proceeding initiated by the City of Sioux Falls. Jury awarded landowner “just compensation of $382,600.” Thereafter, the Trial Judge awarded landowner “reasonable attorney fees of $139,724.60.” City appeals the attorney fee award. The SD Supreme Court affirmed. This is a unanimous (5-0) decision, with opinion authored by Chief Justice Jensen. [NOTE, although I don’t normally keep track and report the identity of the trial judge, I see that Hon. Jeffrey C. Clapper (a former student) was the trial judge here. I am not sure I have seen his name “on appeal” before. But maybe – my memory isn’t as good as it used to be.]
KING v. KING, 2025 S.D. 67: In this divorce action the trial court treated H’s “pending lawsuit against his former business partners as a marital asset,” awarding it to H at a value of $350,000. H appeals this aspect of the divorce judgment. The SD Supreme Court affirmed in a unanimous (5-0) decision, with opinion by Justice Salter. The Court also awarded W appellate attorney fees of $7,812.50. [NOTE: The resolution of this appeal rested easily upon the fact that SD is an “all property” state, per SDCL 25-4-44.]
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Thursday, November 13, 2025
4 new SD Supreme Court Decisions, Nov 13, 2025
The SD Supreme Court handed down four (4) decisions this morning:
1) Attorney Disciplined;
2) Rule 60(b) entitles relief from summary judgment;
3) Dispute relating to construction of research facility in Brookings;
4) H given relief as to omitted assets in divorce proceeding.
Summaries follow:
DISCIPLINE OF VOLESKY, 2025 S.D. 62: This is an attorney disciplinary proceeding. Footnote 1 of the Opinion points out that this attorney’s “conduct included commencing a lawsuit against the members of this Court and alleging the Court had fabricated evidence.” Proceedings before this opinion and the result of this decision are described in ¶¶ 1, 64 & 65, set forth here:
[¶1.] The Disciplinary Board of the State Bar of South Dakota initiated formal disciplinary proceedings against Attorney Tucker Volesky after concluding that his conduct in handling several lawsuits and the management of his law firm trust account violated the South Dakota Rules of Professional Conduct (Rules). The Board recommended a 30-day suspension of Volesky’s license to practice law. Volesky denied the allegations and this Court appointed retired circuit court Judge Craig Pfeifle (Referee) to conduct an evidentiary hearing. The Referee also determined that Volesky violated the Rules and recommended this Court suspend Volesky’s license to practice law for 30 days and that he be placed on a probationary term of no less than six months. After considering the record and the recommendations of the Board and the Referee, we conclude Volesky violated the Rules and impose discipline.
* * *
[¶64.] Finally, after weighing the serious and intentional conduct by Volesky, the recommendations of the Board, the Referee, and the entirety of the record, we conclude that the considerations of maintaining the integrity of the profession and deterring similar conduct by other lawyers require a significant suspension. The Court hereby suspends Volesky’s license to practice law in South Dakota for a period of 90 days, with a probationary period of two years upon reinstatement. The suspension shall commence on the date of entry of the order of suspension, which shall follow this opinion.
[¶65.] During the probationary period, Volesky must meet quarterly with a mentor attorney, approved by the Board, who is able to provide general guidance and assistance to Volesky. Volesky must provide his mentor attorney with copies of any civil complaints filed in state and federal courts; provide a quarterly update to the mentor on the progress of such civil litigation; comply with any other conditions required by the Board; and provide the Board with access to his trust account records as requested. Pursuant to SDCL 16-19-70.4, Volesky shall reimburse the State Bar of South Dakota for all costs and expenses related to these proceedings and must pay the sanction issued against him by Judge Smith, both of which shall be paid prior to his reinstatement to practice law in South Dakota.
This ruling is a 4-1 decision, with opinion authored by Chief Justice Jensen. Justice Salter disagrees and would enter an order of disbarment, stating, “the stark question of whether an unrepentant lawyer who is willing to make a baseless allegation that a court is corrupt in order to obtain a litigation advantage should have a license to practice law. The answer, in my view, is no, and I don’t think it’s a close call.”
COYLE v. MCFARLAND, 2025 S.D. 63: This is a dispute between neighboring landowners in Butte County. The trial court granted a summary judgment for Plaintiffs early in the proceeding, denying Defendant’s motion for continuance. New Counsel took over and sought relief under Rule 60(b). Trial Judge denied relief. The SD Supreme Court reversed and remanded, holding:
[¶51.] The relevant factors related to requests for a continuance supported a finding that excusable neglect existed under the circumstances here. We conclude that the circuit court abused its discretion by not giving due consideration to the fact that the litigation was in its infancy and no discovery had occurred, the [Defendants’ meritorious request for Rule 56(f) relief, the nature of their counsel’s personal circumstances, and the lack of actual prejudice to the [Plaintiffs]. We therefore reverse and remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
This is a 4-1 decision, with opinion authored by Justice DeVaney. Justice Myren dissented, stating that he believed the trial judge did not abuse its discretion.
RTI, LLC v. PRO ENGINEERING, ET AL., 2025 S.D. 64: This is an action initiated by an owner/contractor who “sought to build a clinical research facility (the Facility) in Brookings, South Dakota.” The construction did not go well and Plaintiffs seek relief against an architect and contractors. The trial court granted summary judgment to all Defendants on all claims, holding that that Plaintiffs would be unable to produce adequate expert testimony necessary to make a submissible case. The SD Supreme Court reversed in part and remanded. The final five ¶¶s of the Opinion explain the result on appeal:
[¶76.] The systems at issue in this case involve specialized equipment, processes, parts, and services. Expert testimony is, therefore, required for RTI to sustain its claims against designArc, Pro Engineering, and FM, and Nevins lacks the expertise required to provide such testimony. Accordingly, as to those defendants, the circuit court properly granted summary judgment.
[¶77.] However, [Plaintiff] has alleged facts that if proven, support its causes of action for breach of contract and breach of implied warranties against Trane. [Plaintiff] has also alleged that Ekern is vicariously liable for Trane’s defective work—a claim that the circuit court failed to address. The circuit court, therefore, erred in granting Trane’s and Ekern’s motions for summary judgment.
[¶78.] Finally, the negligence claim that [Plaintiff] sought to assert against Trane, and the vicarious liability claim against Ekern are not futile. And Trane and Ekern have not shown that they would be prejudiced by the proposed amendments. Accordingly, the circuit court erred in denying [Plaintiff’s] motion to amend the complaint.
[¶79.] To summarize, we affirm the court’s order granting summary judgment to designArc, Pro Engineering, and FM. We reverse the circuit court’s order granting Trane’s and Ekern’s motions for summary judgment and the circuit court’s denial of [Plaintiff’s] motion to amend its complaint. The matter is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
[¶80.] Affirmed in part and reversed in part.
This decision is unanimous (5-0) with opinion authored by Justice Kern.
TRUMBLE v. TRUMBLE, 2025 S.D. 65: In this divorce case, the parties’ Canadian real estate had burned down. W represented that this was the sole policy of insurance and that it was in the amount of $2 million Canadian. The parties agree W should be given all of it. After the divorce, H discovered that W actually received $4 million, not $2 million and sought relief under Rule 60(b)(3) (fraudulent concealment). The trial court granted relief, ordering “that the undisclosed proceeds be split evenly between the parties.” The SD Supreme Court affirmed and also awarded H appellate attorney fees of “$6,253.66, plus printing costs in the amount of $37.17.” This decision is unanimous with opinion authored by Justice Kern. [NOTE: there is also an issue, not summarized here, related to the disposition of the proceeds pending the appeal.]
These decisions may be accessed at
http://ujs.sd.gov/Supreme_Court/opinions.aspx .
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)